Raids, Politics, and Public Health Collide in the Fight for Consumer Choice

Vaping Man in Hood

Flavored Vapes are at the Center of a $9 billion Showdown—Will Harm Reduction Win over Regulation?

The federal government and e-cigarettes can’t seem to get along. Like two cats fighting, it’s mostly terrible noises and ridiculous posturing with extended pauses between any actual bouts of scratches and bites.

Yet something about a recent dustup seems to signal the feud has reached a new intensity. It began at the end of October when federal agents seized $76 million worth of product.

The bust—a joint operation by the Customs and Border Protection Agency and the Food and Drug Administration—was ostensibly a raid on illegal e-cigarettes. But it was more accurately seen as proof that government warning letters have teeth. Following years of papering retailers, the feds got fed up.

The seizure happened just weeks before the Supreme Court heard arguments in FDA v. Wages and White Lion Investments, the case that could decide the fate of flavored vaping products.

The seizure happened just weeks before the Supreme Court heard arguments in FDA v. Wages and White Lion Investments, the case that could decide the fate of flavored vaping products.

This, um, coincidental timing brings us to a profound moment. As a new administration settles into its role in Washington and the Supreme Court mulls over the recent arguments, the vaping industry must brace for news on two separate fronts—each one capable of capsizing the market.

The Political Angle

The second Trump administration strolled into the midst of a vaping policy disaster. Thanks to bad laws and worse execution, the great majority of vape sales happen in a gray space between strictly legal and not.

Part of that is his own fault. During his first term, Trump appointed five different people to head the FDA. The whiplash of new commissioners kept the agency in constant limbo with unclear priorities and guidelines.

Then there’s the law itself. The FDA wasn’t allowed to regulate vaping products until 2016—a full 11 years after e-cigarettes came on the market. Since the beginning, the process has been a cluster.

“The manifold problems begin with the FDA’s authorization process for e-cigarettes,” wrote Alli Boughner, vice president of American Vapor Manufacturers. “The agency’s regulatory approach is designed to ensure that a product appeals to adult smokers without enticing non-smokers, especially children. It seems like a reasonable standard, but the PMTA (Premarket Tobacco Application) is a nightmare for applicants.”

Indeed, the process is expensive, time-consuming, and rarely leads to approval. Of the millions of product applications the agency has received since 2016, it’s approved only a couple dozen.

This is exactly the type of problem Trump promised to solve. During his campaign, he took to Truth Social to proclaim his intention to “save Vaping again!” And while that’s not exactly what happened, it contains a bit of truth: It was Trump’s administration that split the baby the first time lawmakers wanted to axe flavored vapes. In a true compromise, Trump proposed limiting the ban to only cartridge-based devices while allowing single-use and e-liquid refills to continue carrying better-tasting products.

Like all good compromises, it couldn’t last. And this time around, the Vaping Voting Bloc that Trump actively courted—around 15 million Americans—wants better assurances.

The President has signaled two efforts to help the industry. First, he wants to roll back federal agencies’ ability to regulate the industry, which could strip the FDA of its vice-like grip on vaping products. Second, and more importantly, advisors close to the President have said he views flavored vapes as a states’ rights issue, meaning he’d like the federal government to wash its hands of vaping regulations once and for all.

That could leave the country in another patchwork of legal drama as some states outlaw flavors while others don’t, much like cannabis. It would certainly mean hard times for smoke shops in places like Iowa and Florida, but it would be better than a nationwide ban.

The Kids Are Alright?

Of course, the battle wages beyond the regulatory environment. On the other front, Supreme Court justices are now weighing the latest evidence for and against flavor vapes. While much of the arguments will sound familiar, a few data points should be clearer than before: critics of vaping have overplayed their hand for years.

Despite the harm that vaping can cause, all the best research suggests that flavored vaping devices are excellent at keeping people off much-deadlier cigarettes. They’re scientifically proven harm-reduction strategies.

The latest research shows that wherever flavored e-cigs are outlawed, smokers return to old-fashioned combustibles. Yet when politicians voice support for bans, they do so out of concern for a specific niche of public health: those poor kids.
But Gen. Z isn’t like previous youngsters. They drink less, they have less sex, and they’re not using tobacco products. According to the latest National Youth Tobacco Survey, less than eight percent of high schoolers vape with any regularity. That’s a far cry from the 2019 numbers, which showed vaping was popular with more than a quarter of American teens.

Is eight percent too high? Some concerned parent groups might like that number to be zero, but many believe it’s simply not practical to attempt to out-legislate youthful rebellion.

“Kids always want what adults have. Kids smoked tons of cigarettes before there was a vape. And now, they’re going to get their hands on vapes. That’s just a fact of life,” said Joey DeStefano, Chief Commercial Officer at Puff Brands. “These flavored vapes, they’re not made for kids. Yes, there are some bad actors that create vapes with video games with dumb shit on them, but most of us make vapes for adults who want an alternative to combustion. I’m 41 years old, and I love blue raspberry. I like flavors. It’s a lot more pleasant to vape something that tastes like a mango than something that’s trying its best to taste like tobacco.”

What is clear in our vaping moment is this: The stakes are high. With more than 400,000 Americans dying each year from smoking-related illnesses and a $9 billion vaping industry hanging in the balance, the question isn’t just about flavoring. It’s about whether our public health policy can evolve to embrace harm reduction or if we’ll need to rely on another decade of small business raids and moral panic to flavor our lives.

Recent Articles

The day after an electric Blunt Brunch Nationals event at MJBizCon last December, co-founders Adelia Fakhri (formerly Carrillo) and Parisa Mansouri-Rad celebrated their success in style—with glam, neon, and most importantly, with their community. Part of what sets Adelia and Parisa apart from other industry leaders is their insistence on collaboration over competition. They’re not trying to climb to the top alone, and their Bright Women, Bold Futures photo series shows how much fun it can be to lift each other up along the way.
It’s the most wonderful time of the year! Well, if you enjoy cannabis products, that joy can also come on sunny days in September or meh mornings in March. But the Christmas season is when most families and friends—religious, secular, or somewhere in-between—come together to celebrate with shiny tinsel, stuffed stockings, and warm egg nog.
Modern pop culture is full of overt references to cannabis use. Counterculture icons Cheech & Chong carved entire careers on their stoner comedy. Musical artists like Cypress Hill, with cuts that include “Hits from the Bong,” “Stoned Raiders,” and “Dr. Greenthumb,” have been celebrating cannabis in all its glory since the early 1990s. And let’s not forget films like Half-Baked, Pineapple Express, and the Harold & Kumar series.
Ten seconds. That's all it takes for a customer to lose interest and your cart size to shrink. It is not that your customers don't know how to focus; rather, they have many things competing for their attention. Nick Gary, founder of IGU Global, calls it a growing impatience for uncertainty. According to Nick, customers will stay in the store if it's answering their needs. Every second they spend asking what something is, how much it costs, or how stupid they might feel asking a question is a second closer to a decision to leave.
Trading cards are having a moment. Have you seen the excitement surrounding limited-edition releases, rare pulls, and collectible cards tied to everything from professional athletes to pop-culture icons? Collectors are not simply buying cards. They are chasing the thrill of discovering, trading, and owning something special.
With Halloweentime upon us, ghosts and goblins all around the world are gearing up for the annual celebration of the macabre. Between dressing up in fun costumes and making caramel apples to taking our kids trick-or-treating around the neighborhood, there’s no shortage of things to do at the end of October; but did you know that some of the earliest traditions revolved around the use of incense and other herbal blends?
When I was in college, my sophomore year roommate, who went by Bear, had a two-foot-tall bong with a name. Green Lucy was a gorgeous emerald-colored masterpiece with thick, bulbous glass at the top, comfortable for ripping huge hits. It was a celebrity on our floor of the creative arts co-op where we lived. People would come from all over the house, and sometimes from other parts of campus, just to hang with Bear and get baked from Green Lucy.